Homework Help: Questions and Answers: What is an architectural impact of middleboxes on the traditional Internet model?
A. They maintain a clear separation between network and transport/application layers.
B. They solely focus on enhancing network performance.
C. They replace the need for routers.
D. They violate the separation between network and transport/application layers.
E. They simplify the network layer.
Answer:
First, let’s understand what Traditional Internet Model is:
The Internet is traditionally based on the end-to-end principle:
- The network layer (Layer 3 in the OSI model) focuses on forwarding packets (IP routing).
- The transport and application layers (Layers 4 and above) are responsible for handling end-to-end communication like error checking, flow control (TCP), and specific application logic.
In this model, the network’s role is limited to transporting data between endpoints, while the intelligence lies primarily at the endpoints (i.e., the devices communicating).
What are middleboxes?
Middleboxes are devices in the network that perform additional functions, such as:
- Firewalls (security)
- NAT (address translation)
- Load balancers (distribute traffic) These functions often require inspection of data beyond the network layer, such as examining transport layer headers (TCP/UDP) or even application layer data.
Architectural Impact of Middleboxes
Middleboxes violate the end-to-end principle by interfering with or inspecting transport/application layer information, which traditionally would only be processed at the endpoints (client and server). For example:
- NAT rewrites packet headers, which affects how TCP connections are established.
- Firewalls may block or modify packets based on transport or application layer information.
Given Options: Step by Step Answering
a) They maintain a clear separation between network and transport/application layers
- This is incorrect because middleboxes often blur the separation by inspecting or modifying data in higher layers.
b) They solely focus on enhancing network performance
- While some middleboxes like load balancers enhance performance, many (such as firewalls and NATs) serve other purposes such as security and address management.
c) They replace the need for routers
- Middleboxes do not replace routers; they complement routers by adding additional functionality.
d) They violate the separation between network and transport/application layers
- This is the correct answer. Middleboxes often analyze or manipulate data in the transport and application layers, breaching the separation defined in the traditional Internet model.
e) They simplify the network layer
- This is incorrect because middleboxes often add complexity by introducing additional processing steps, policies, and functionalities at various layers of the network.
Final Answer:
Based on the above analysis, the correct answer is:
D. They violate the separation between network and transport/application layers.
Learn More: Homework Help
Q. What has led to the proliferation of middleboxes in recent years?
Q. Which statement best describes Network Address Translation (NAT)?
Q. What does the CCValidate object do to improve security?